Monicasdude (Gilbert Walker) has
caused many problems at Wikipedia
Wikipedia:Requests
for arbitration/Monicasdude/Workshop edit
extracted from
Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
Highlights from the page
found at:
http://allrss.com/wikipedia.php?title=Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Monicasdude/Workshop#Monicasdude_is_uncivil
Monicasdude is uncivil
1) Monicasdude has frequently been uncivil to other editors and
administrators, including making personal attacks.
Monicasdude assumes bad faith
2) Monicasdude has, both implicitly and explicitly, attributed the
actions of others to bad faith and/or vandalism. These assumptions of
bad faith have often been stated inappropriately in edit summaries.
Monicasdude ignores consensus
3) Monicasdude feels strongly that his opinion of policy is correct.
This assumption often leads him to ignore consensus or discussion of
disputed issues.
3.1) Monicasdude has disrupted Wikipedia:Articles for deletion debates
by frequently making contrary votes and tendentiously arguing with
anyone who disagrees with him.
Comment by others:
Agreed. RGTraynor 14:11, 3 May 2006 (UTC)
3.1.1) Monicasdude has disrupted Wikipedia:Articles for deletion
debates by tendentiously arguing with anyone who disagrees with him.
Comment by others:
Monicasdude has refused attempts
at dispute resolution
4) Monicasdude has refused to participate in the dispute resolution
process in good faith, making only argumentative responses to his
Request for Comments and Arbitration. Requests to participate in the
second RfC were met with personal attacks.
Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Dunno who came up with this one, but I agree. ⇒
SWATJester Ready Aim Fire! 01:54, 21 April 2006 (UTC)
Comment by others:
I agree. Ardenn 16:01, 4 May 2006 (UTC)
Monicasdude placed on probation
1) Monicasdude is placed on probation. Should he make any disruptive
edits, attempting ownership of Bob Dylan and personal attacks, he can
be restricted from editing selected pages and it may include a general
ban up to a year.
Support. Teke 17:56, 26 April 2006 (UTC)
Comment by others:
...for one year, more specific
1.1) Monicasdude is placed on probation for one year. He may be banned
for up to one year by any uninvolved administrator from any page he
disrupts.
Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Added by me. Stifle (talk) 22:21, 12 April 2006 (UTC)
Comment by others:
...for indefinite, second option
1.2) Monicasude is placed on probation indefinitely. Should he make
disruptive edits, he may be banned up to one year by any uninvolved
administrator from any page he disrupts.
...sockpuppet probation
1.3) ...[whatever is approved of the above] Should he create a
sockpuppet established by checkuser to bypass any remedy, he may be
banned for up to x.
Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Support per recent evidence to show disruptive
sockpuppet usage. ⇒ SWATJester Ready Aim Fire! 12:26, 7 May 2006 (UTC)
Monicasdude banned for a year
Monicasdude is banned for a year for disruptive editing at FAC
processes, attempted ownership of Bob Dylan article and removing
{{prod}} tags at articles as well as personal attacks at users who
disagree with him.
these are just a few
highlights to show the disruption that Gilbert Walker has caused at
Wiki. The entire article is quite lengthy
|