is STILL reaching out to Gil Walker in vain attempts at resolution
A disinterested third party (who is one of the most well known and well respected names in the Dylan community) contacted Gilbert in February to ask him to consider a peaceful resolution, to no avail.

Then, the following two emails were sent to him by representation in March, 2008. He did not respond.

If he wants to claim that he never received emails, then we welcome his response to this online page via
Via E-form

All the wrongs that [Gilbert Walker] has committed against us, he has done secretly and under the cover of darkness.
Our responses to him will be made in the light of day for all to see.
Dr.CD Pinkerton     Jan. 2008

Return to the proof page

April 10, 2008
FROM: "JG" <lawoffices.....> | Save Address
DATE:           Fri, 21 Mar 2008 00:40:28 -0500
TO:           <>  
SUBJECT:           Re: your trouble with
After a week of no reply, I can only assume that you have no desire for any type of peaceable resolution in this matter, no matter how little is asked of you. I shall advise CD Pinkerton and the site accordingly.


---------- Original Message ----------------------------------
FROM: "JG" <lawoffices......> | Save Address
DATE:  Fri, 14 Mar 2008 12:54:05 -0500
TO:           <>  
SUBJECT:           Re: your trouble with

>There is no one that's evil at As a matter of fact, these are some of the sweetest, most caring, most honest and honorable people I have ever met in my life. There is no grudge held against you. Dr. C just finally couldn't take the libel anymore, and had to try to clear his name. The only thing that they want is for this thing to go away. That's the only thing that they ever wanted.
>No one here sells bootlegs. No one here even knows anyone that sells bootlegs. They are not a front for dealers, They simply house a visual museum of commercial bootlegs as an educational website. The small amount of legit retail items that is sold doesn't even pay for the huge cost of the site.
>No one has ever stolen your material. Titles and dates and venues and song names that you had typed up were used inadvertently a few times in the past... but to the best of everyone's knowledge it's now all been retyped by hand so that they can truly say that nothing was cut and pasted. Please understand, though, there is no copyright protection on these things. You can go to and copy and paste CD titles, track lists, dates, and venues all that you would like. There is no copyright that can be held on them.
>Why must you go on and on about all the things that you continue to say that are not true?
>Here is a good faith offer for you.
> will tear down every page about you today. They would like nothing more.
>In return, all that they ask is for
>1) the libel to stop and never again appear
>2) your gentleman's agreement to never again do anything (such as contact their patrons, sponsors, website host, business associates, etc etc) in an effort to cause them harm.
>3) your agreement to post to chat rooms, etc. (in conjunction with that peaceful terms have been met and that no more negative posts will appear from either side. is not asking that you publicly admit to wrong doing. Only that there has been an agreement made.
>Please consider this request. It asks so little of you.... only that you do the right thing.
>In return you have SO MUCH to gain.
>Awaiting your reply to this email address
>thank you
>JG       for


Voice your comments
Return to the proof page